- Fabletics vs. Athleta in 2026: Which Leggings and Matching Sets Should You Buy? - November 16, 2026
- Fabletics Review 2026: The Best Pieces I’ve Tried and How VIP Works - November 8, 2026
- Best Women’s Activewear Brands of 2026: 8 Brands for Every Workout and Bud - November 4, 2026
I’ve been adding more matching sets to my workout wardrobe lately. There’s something about having a cute outfit ready to go that makes me a little more excited to get dressed for the gym. Fabletics and Athleta both have plenty of styles I’d happily wear, but a matching set has to do more than look good for me to keep reaching for it.
If I’m constantly pulling up the waistband, worrying about the fabric being see-through, or trying to squeeze my phone into a pocket that’s barely big enough to hold it, those leggings probably aren’t going to get much wear. I’ve found several pieces from Fabletics that have become regulars in my workout rotation, which made me curious about how they compare with some of Athleta’s most popular styles.
The Short Answer
Fabletics gets my vote for supportive workout leggings and coordinating outfits, particularly during VIP promotions. Its On-the-Go PowerHold High-Waisted Leggings stay put through movements that usually send me tugging at my waistband, and I like how easily I can mix and match my tops and bottoms. Fabletics also tends to have more playful colors and fashion-forward sets.
Athleta has more understated styles, which is nice if you like to keep it on the down-low that you’re running errands in your workout clothes. Its retail prices are comparable to Fabletics’ nonmember prices, so it’s an especially good option if you don’t want to manage a monthly membership. I also like its Give-It-a-Workout Guarantee, which lets you exercise in eligible pieces before deciding whether to keep them.
PowerHold vs. PowerMove: Leggings for Strength Training
My On-the-Go PowerHold High-Waisted Leggings are my benchmark for training tights. PowerHold is Fabletics’ maximum-compression fabric, and that firm feel is what I want for lifting. Some high-compression leggings remind me of shapewear, where I feel like I’m fighting against the fabric every time I move. PowerHold feels more like it’s working with me, giving me the support I want without restricting my movements.

My thighs tend to pull leggings down during squats and lunges, so I was a little hesitant to size up when I found myself between sizes. I’m glad I did, though, because the waistband stays put without digging in, and they’re still squat-proof, even in the lighter color I chose. I can get through my workout without constantly readjusting my leggings, which is a big plus for me.
I also like having side pockets so I don’t have to leave my phone on the gym floor. My iPhone 17 Pro Max fits, although it looks a little like a hostage situation once it’s in there. At least I know my phone isn’t going anywhere.
Athleta’s PowerMove Smooth Rise Legging is probably the closest match to my PowerHold leggings. PowerMove is Athleta’s highest-compression fabric, and these leggings are designed for more intense workouts. They’re full length with a high-rise waistband, pockets, and no front seam.

The adjustable drawstring inside the waistband caught my attention. Finding leggings that fit my thighs without being too loose around my waist can be a struggle, so being able to tighten the waistband without going down a size makes a lot of sense to me.
I’d want to try these on before buying, though. Some early customer reviews on Athleta’s product page mention pockets that are too small for a phone and frustration with the fit compared with older Athleta training leggings. Given how happy I am with my PowerHold fit, I’m not particularly tempted to switch, but that drawstring could make a difference for someone who’s still struggling with their waistband slipping.
What About Softer Leggings for Yoga and Everyday Wear?
As much as I love my PowerHold leggings for lifting, I don’t always want that much compression for a gentler class. I’ve been wearing my Fabletics Seamless Scrunch High-Waisted Leggings for those workouts. I was a little surprised by how thick and sturdy they felt for leggings with medium-light compression. I still feel supported in them, but they’re more comfortable for an hour-long class where I don’t need that same firm hold.

I also like the little bit of extra shape the scrunch seam gives the back without having to wear a heavily compressive legging. My one complaint is that they don’t have pockets. Considering these are more likely to be the leggings I’m wearing when I run errands after class, I actually miss the pockets more than I do during my workouts.
That’s one reason Athleta’s Salutation Stash High Rise Legging interests me. It’s made from Powervita, a soft, stretchy fabric with gentler support than PowerMove, and has two side pockets. For the days when I’m heading straight from a class to the grocery store, I can see myself getting a lot of wear out of these.

Athleta also has the Elation Ultra High Rise Legging, which has a higher, three-layer waistband if you like a little more structure around your waist. It has a small back pocket instead of side pockets, though, so I’m back to figuring out where to put my phone. The fabric can also vary by color and version, so I’d check the individual product listing for the color I’m considering.
If I wanted something softer than PowerHold without the scrunch seam, I could stay with Fabletics. Its PureLuxe fabric has medium-light compression, and there are styles with pockets. For a pair I’m wearing to class and then out for the afternoon, I want a comfortable waistband, pockets big enough for my phone, and a price I feel good about paying.
Matching Sets and Styling
One of the things I love about Fabletics is that I can find a color I like and build an outfit around it. My Principal Longline Medium Impact Sports Bra is Oxblood, and Fabletics has offered its Seamless Scrunch leggings in the same color. I’m also a fan of my Anywhere Cropped Built-In Bra Tank because it meets the waistband of my high-waisted leggings without showing my stomach. I can still get that cropped look without wearing just a sports bra.

Athleta’s Transcend collection has coordinating leggings, bras, and tanks, so there are plenty of ways to put an outfit together there, too. The Transcend Longline Bra and coordinating Transcend leggings are a nice option for a lighter-impact workout. If you tend to gravitate toward neutrals and simpler designs, Athleta has a lot to choose from. Fabletics carries plenty of classic colors as well, but I enjoy some of its more playful details, like the scrunch seams, crisscross straps, and brighter seasonal colors.
I also like that I don’t have to buy an entire outfit to get the look I want. If I already have leggings in a particular color, I can just pick up another top to go with them. But if I’m starting from scratch, Fabletics’ curated outfits and VIP Credit bundles can be a much better deal than buying everything separately, especially when I can get a complete matching set for the price of a single pair of leggings.
How the Prices Really Compare
Fabletics and Athleta aren’t far apart at regular retail prices, but Fabletics’ VIP membership makes a considerable difference in what I actually pay.
| Item | Fabletics Retail | Fabletics VIP | Athleta Retail |
| On-the-Go PowerHold vs. PowerMove Smooth Rise | $94.95 | $69.95 | $109 |
| Seamless Scrunch vs. Salutation Stash | $94.95 | $69.95 | $109 |
| Principal vs. Transcend Longline Bra | $64.95 | $44.95 | $59 |
| Total for All Three Pieces | $254.85 | $184.85 | $277 |
These are the prices available to me as a Fabletics VIP member, although member prices and promotions can change.
Without a membership, there’s only a $22.15 difference between the two brands for those three pieces. With my VIP pricing, I’m saving $92.15 compared with Athleta’s retail prices. That’s enough to pick up another pair of leggings.
New VIP members often have access to even deeper discounts. The introductory offers change, but if you’re looking to add a few matching sets to your workout wardrobe, that first purchase can be considerably less expensive.
Athleta runs its own sales, too, and its Elation Ultra High Rise Legging is actually less expensive than my Seamless Scrunch leggings at regular retail prices. With VIP pricing, Fabletics comes out ahead in this comparison. The question is whether those savings make a membership worthwhile for how often you shop.
Fabletics VIP Pricing, Without the Confusion
Fabletics VIP members get 20%–50% off eligible styles, but the discounts come with a membership. Unless you skip between the 1st and 5th of the month, you’ll be charged $69.95. That gives you a VIP Credit to use toward an eligible item or qualifying outfit. A single credit can even cover a matching set, which is one of my favorite things about the program.
You can skip as often as you like and still shop at VIP prices. You won’t be charged or receive a new credit for that month. I forgot to skip once, so now I have a calendar reminder at the beginning of each month. Unused credits expire after 12 months, and you can cancel your membership if it’s no longer working for you.
Athleta’s Encore rewards program is free, with no monthly charge or deadline to remember. If you prefer to shop when you need something without keeping track of a membership, Athleta has the simpler setup.
Quality, Fit, and Returns
After several weeks of wearing and washing my Fabletics pieces, I’m happy with how they’re holding up. I haven’t noticed any pilling, particularly between the thighs, where I tend to see wear first.
Both brands offer an extensive size range. Fabletics carries selected leggings in XXS through 4X with short and tall lengths, while Athleta offers selected styles through 3X in petite, regular, and tall. Finding matching pieces in the same color can get a little trickier when you need a specific length, though.
Athleta has an advantage when it comes to trying a new fit. With its Give-It-a-Workout Guarantee, you can actually exercise in eligible leggings and return them within 30 days if they don’t perform as expected. Fabletics also offers 30-day returns and exchanges on eligible items, but they generally need to be unworn. Trying on leggings in a dressing room only tells me so much, so I really like that Athleta gives you a chance to see how they hold up during a workout.
Which Brand Would I Buy?
Fabletics is still my first choice. Finding leggings that fit my thighs without constantly sliding down has always been a struggle, so I’m pretty happy to have found PowerHold. I already have my eye on a few more colors, and at VIP prices, I can pick up another matching set for less than I’d normally spend on leggings alone.
For those who prefer more understated styles or want to shop without a membership, Athleta has plenty to offer. I also wish more activewear brands had a return policy like Athleta’s. Sometimes it takes a full workout to figure out whether a pair of leggings is going to work for you.

